Enduring, transformative change requires an approach of justice and solidarity
Fundamentally, we believe that transformative change in global development necessitates stances of justice and solidarity, in contrast to the current models of charity and aid.
Philanthropy has long been considered a form of charity or aid, in which those with wealth and resources identify worthy causes and donate to them. Often these funds are given with considerable restrictions around how they may be spent, and are accompanied by a long list of requirements for monitoring, reporting, and evidence of results.
This charity approach to global development is deeply flawed. Despite good intentions and generally thoughtful implementation, charity approaches often involve symptomatic and short-term fixes, and usually do not address underlying systemic issues or root causes. Moreover, power tends to lie with the donor who determines who is worthy of receiving funds, how the funds may be used, and how success is defined. This results in initiatives, approaches, strategies, and actions that are deemed appropriate by usually Global North, white, wealthy people – whose perspectives and lenses are at best limited and narrow, but at worst biased and even self-interested in maintaining underlying social and economic structures.
A justice approach to global development, on the other hand, is about fairness, rights, and the equitable distribution of money, opportunities, and power among all members of society. With a justice approach, symptomatic and reactive fixes are inadequate – it is necessary to expose and redress that which is unfair and inequitable. Justice approaches often go hand in hand with a commitment of solidarity – the sense that we are all responsible to fight injustice towards ourselves and others. This sense of solidarity is more in line with the original meaning of the word ‘philanthropy’ – that is, love of one’s fellow humanity.
Community-driven systems change – the approach that Firelight takes in all of its work - as an approach is a clear way to operationalize justice and solidarity. It requires donors and other holders of power and wealth to walk with, and even be guided by, people and communities, in the messy, gradual, difficult, and long term work of creating both small and large shifts in underlying systems and norms. This is what it means to be in solidarity with others towards a more just and equitable world.